Paul N. Merideth

Most of us know the feeling of a bait-and-switch. The ad promises one thing; the experience delivers another. As a teenager, I was hired at a restaurant as a cook. I was eager to learn the art of culinary creation, but on my first shift, they pointed me to the sink. Their dishwasher had just quit, they said. Shift after shift, it became clear they never meant to train me. They needed a dishwasher and knew no one would apply for that job. Needless to say, my culinary career was short-lived.

Do visitors to our churches ever feel the same way? Our websites and invitations promise a loving family, meaningful friendships, and a place where everyone belongs. Every church claims, of course, to be the friendliest in town. We tell newcomers, “There’s a place for you here,” and assure new members we’ll be there, whatever the need. Those are wonderful promises. But what happens when someone believes us?

A new member attends for weeks without a single invitation to lunch. An awkward newcomer stands alone in the foyer while old friends drift toward one another. From the pulpit we announce, “We just love one another here,” while strife festers behind the scenes. No one meant to exclude anyone. Yet the community we advertised is not the one they found.

I don’t believe most of us set out to deceive anyone. More often, we’ve confused what we hope to be with what we’re prepared to practice. Good intentions are not the same as faithful follow-through.

But visitors can’t see our intentions. They can only see what we do. And young people especially can smell fake a mile away. They’ve grown up with a sales pitch on every screen, and they know one when they hear it. When they catch a whiff of pseudo-Christianity, they rarely say a word. They simply slip out the back door, and too many never set foot in a church again.

That should sober every one of us. Jesus said, “By this all people will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another” (John 13:35). So when our love turns out to be counterfeit, people don’t just give up on us. They give up on him.

Where do we start? With the welcome we ourselves received. Paul writes, “Welcome one another as Christ has welcomed you” (Romans 15:7). And how did Christ welcome us? Not merely with a smile and a handshake at the door. He ate with tax collectors and sinners (Luke 15:1–2). He reached out and touched a leper everyone else kept at arm’s length (Mark 1:41). And he died for us while we were still his enemies (Romans 5:8–10). That’s why John urges, “Let us not love in word or talk but in deed and in truth” (1 John 3:18). Biblical hospitality means making room in our lives: bearing burdens, noticing needs, and patiently building relationships.

None of that can be faked for long. We can wear a costume of conviction for an hour on Sunday morning, but only the character of Christ shows up on a Tuesday night when a new family’s baby is sick and they don’t know who else to call.

I realize no congregation can manufacture instant friendship. We cannot promise immediate connection, but we can promise intentional love. Nobody who comes to us looking for a family should end up stuck at the sink. So before we announce some new upbeat outreach initiative, let’s ask a harder diagnostic question: If someone accepts our invitation, will they find the church we told them about?

Let’s not simply advertise a community worth joining. By God’s grace, let’s become the community we project.

Red distressed vintage-style stamp graphic with the word “AUTHENTIC” prominently displayed.

Leave a Reply